Best Pop-Tart Not Made by a Guy Named Ted

Spring Mill Bread Company
Multiple locations
You’ve probably eaten the pop-tarts at Ted’s Bulletin. (Full disclosure: I’ve gorged on too many to count.) But if you’re looking to switch up your toaster-treat routine, try the beauties at Spring Mill Bread Company. Rather than using a simple sweet crust to pocket the jam, they employ two layers of butter-rich shortbread. These sandwich a layer of slightly tart blackberry, rich raspberry, or sweet strawberry preserves. Finished off with racing stripes of white icing and a rainbow of nonpareils, they’re worthy of a quick, envy-inducing Instagram before you gobble them up. The bakery often sells out, so go early if you don’t want to walk away disappointed.